Tag: EU Emissions Trading System

  • German Lignite Operator LEAG Pushes to Suspend Coal Phase-Out and Exit EU Carbon Market as Iran War Reshapes Energy Calculus

    German Lignite Operator LEAG Pushes to Suspend Coal Phase-Out and Exit EU Carbon Market as Iran War Reshapes Energy Calculus

    Eastern Germany’s largest lignite plant operator LEAG is lobbying state governments in Brandenburg and Saxony to keep domestic coal production running beyond planned phase-out timelines, arguing that the energy crisis triggered by the Iran war has fundamentally altered the conditions under which Germany’s coal exit was agreed.

    According to an internal company presentation reported by business weekly WirtschaftsWoche, LEAG is positioning lignite as a cheap, domestically available alternative to fossil fuel imports disrupted by damage to Persian Gulf energy infrastructure and trade routes. The document, prepared as a briefing ahead of talks with eastern German coal state governments, describes lignite power production as a potentially cost-competitive energy source capable of bolstering Germany’s energy security — but one rendered artificially uncompetitive solely by carbon prices under the EU’s Emissions Trading System.

    LEAG’s proposals include excluding lignite-fired power plants from the ETS for a predetermined period, placing selected plants on security standby while mining continues, and introducing an industry power price that could be set at approximately half the market rate if the state absorbs carbon costs. The company did not deny the reports but described its discussions with state governments as routine engagement ahead of a planned summer monitoring report on Germany’s coal phase-out. It added that the Iran conflict had created “changed framework conditions” that make fresh talks “absolutely necessary.”

    The push finds some political sympathy. Chancellor Friedrich Merz said after the outbreak of the Iran war that Germany may need to delay the closure of individual coal plants in the event of supply shortages. The state governments in Brandenburg and Saxony acknowledged they hold regular talks with LEAG, which is a major employer in their coal mining regions, without confirming receipt of the specific proposals.

    The initiative sits awkwardly against the financial commitments already made around the phase-out. LEAG is set to receive up to 1.75 billion euros under Germany’s coal phase-out law to transition its business toward climate-neutral energy production, while the states themselves are in line for billions of euros in structural adjustment funding ahead of the 2038 phase-out deadline. Removing lignite from the ETS would work directly against one of the trading system’s primary objectives — pushing polluting and inefficient plants out of the market — while market dynamics alone could make coal-fired power generation economically unviable well before 2038, researchers have noted.

    In western Germany, RWE has agreed to end coal-fired power production by 2030, conditional on sufficient backup capacity being installed. The federal economy ministry confirmed on Monday that it had contributed more than a third of 240 million euros in transformation investments in North Rhine-Westphalia, covering battery production and recycling facilities among other projects.

    LEAG’s owner, Czech investor Daniel Kretinsky, has previously criticised the EU’s carbon pricing scheme. The company said that if none of its proposals are accepted, it would consider closing its least efficient plants ahead of schedule.

  • Poland’s Parliament Approves Bill Facilitating Coal Mine Closures and Compensation for Miners

    Poland’s Parliament Approves Bill Facilitating Coal Mine Closures and Compensation for Miners

    Poland’s parliament has approved a landmark government bill aimed at easing the country’s transition away from coal. The new legislation facilitates the closure of coal mines, introduces financial support for displaced miners, and promotes the redevelopment of former mining areas. The measure, which gained strong backing from Prime Minister Donald Tusk’s ruling coalition, is designed to support the country’s shift to cleaner energy sources while mitigating the impact on coal-mining communities.

    The bill, which will allow mining companies to close operations with state-backed financial support, is part of Poland’s broader energy transition plan. Under the legislation, coal mines can transfer their assets to local authorities or state entities for redevelopment projects, creating new opportunities for investment, revitalization, and infrastructure construction in former mining regions. In addition to mine closures, the bill provides protective benefits for workers, including severance payments of up to 170,000 zloty (€40,000) for those losing their jobs.

    The government aims to phase out thermal coal mining entirely by 2049, with an initial target of closing five mines within the next decade. The bill received broad support from MPs within the ruling coalition, with 241 votes in favor and just six against. However, the far-right opposition parties abstained from voting, with some critics arguing that the bill does not adequately provide alternatives to coal for affected communities.

    Poland remains Europe’s most coal-dependent nation, with coal accounting for 57% of its power generation in 2024. The transition away from coal has raised concerns, particularly in the Silesian-Dąbrowa region, home to many of the country’s coal mines. Despite this, the government has emphasised that the bill will help ensure a “just transition” for miners and stimulate new investment in coal regions.

    The legislation now heads to Poland’s Senate for approval before reaching President Karol Nawrocki’s desk for signing into law. While Nawrocki has previously voiced strong support for the coal industry, it remains to be seen whether he will sign the bill or veto it.